Illustration for How to Screen Tenants the Right Way

Landlord Guide

How to Screen Tenants the Right Way

Last reviewed: October 2026

By the ONYX Real Estate LLC Team · 5 min read

The tenant you choose is the biggest decision you make as an owner. A good tenant pays on time and takes care of your home. A poor choice can cost months of lost rent and thousands in repairs. The best protection is a written, consistent screening process that you apply to every applicant.

Set your criteria in writing first

Decide your standards before you advertise and write them down: minimum income, credit expectations, rental history requirements, and occupancy limits. Give the same written criteria to every applicant. Changing the rules for one person is how most Fair Housing problems begin.

What to check

  • Application: a complete, signed application for every adult.
  • Identity: a government-issued photo ID.
  • Income: recent pay stubs, an offer letter or tax records. Many owners look for monthly income of about three times the rent.
  • Credit report: look at payment history and overall debt, not just the score.
  • Rental history: call current and former landlords. Ask about on-time payments, property care and lease compliance.
  • Background screening: use a reputable screening company and follow the rules that apply in your area.

Follow Fair Housing rules

Federal law prohibits discrimination based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, disability, familial status and more. Pennsylvania and local laws, including Philadelphia's, can add further protections and can limit how criminal history and income sources may be considered. Never base a decision on a protected characteristic, and apply every standard to every applicant.

Tell applicants when you say no

If you deny an application or offer different terms because of information in a credit or screening report, federal law generally requires you to tell the applicant in writing and give the name of the reporting company. Keep records of every application and decision.

Red flags worth a closer look

Incomplete or inconsistent applications, refusal to allow a credit check, a landlord reference who is a friend or relative, pressure to move in before screening is done, and income that cannot be verified.

Let ONYX handle it

Our team advertises your rental, screens every applicant against written criteria, verifies income and rental history, and handles the lease signing, so you get a qualified tenant without the guesswork.

Learn how our leasing and management packages work

← Back to articles

This article is general information, not legal or financial advice. Laws change. Please contact ONYX Real Estate LLC or a licensed attorney about your situation.